Home › Island News › Local News
Marco, Sanibel managers in top 10 for Naples city manager post
STORY TOOLS
Tell us about it
- What would you add to this story? Tell us what we missed.
- Do you have photos from this event? Documents we need to see? Share with us.
- Upload photos & videos
- More ways to get your stuff online and in the paper.
More Local News
- Man's best friend lost in Goodland house fire
- Electric takeover committee asks "why should we buy?"
- Residents ask ‘why now’ for city-run electric
Share and Enjoy [?]
Read the resumes here
- Wm. G. Hinchey 1.1MB .pdf file
- Samuel E. Grove 1.1MB .pdf file
- Patrick G. Salerno 1.1MB .pdf file
- Linda Lovvorn Tucker 1.1MB .pdf file
- Kent A. Myers 1.1MB .pdf file
- Judith Ann Zimomra 1.1MB .pdf file
- Hector A. Rivera, Sr. 1.1MB .pdf file
- Bruce St. Denis 1.1MB .pdf file
- A. William Moss 1.1MB .pdf file
- Daniel W. Fitzpatrick 1.1MB .pdf file
And then there were 10.
The Naples City Council narrowed its list of city manager candidates from 61 to 10 during Monday’s workshop.
The list has five Florida candidates, including Marco Island City Manager Bill Moss and Sanibel Island City Manager Judith Zimomra.
Also on the list is former Cape Coral Assistant City Manager Hector Rivera. Rivera lost his job earlier this year because of budget cuts, according to Thomas Freijo, vice president of The Mercer Group Inc., the search firm hired by the city to conduct the manager search.
“I’m impressed with the quality of the candidates,” Councilman Gary Price said.
All of the candidates, save one, were on the initial list of 16 that Freijo provided to council during Monday’s meeting. Mayor Bill Barnett asked that Sam Grove, Cartersville, Ga., city manager, be placed on the list for consideration.
Moss told Marco Island City Council members last week that he planned to apply for the position. At the time, Moss said he was happy on the island, but felt that Naples’ vision statement was something he could support.
Moss also told members of the Marco Island council that he doesn’t plan to look for another job if he isn’t chosen for the Naples position.
“It’s a long way to the finish line,” Moss said Monday. “As I anticipated, they have a very good list of finalists.”
Councilman John Nocera said he was pleased to see that Moss made the cut.
“He’s one of my top picks,” he said. “(But) they’re all good.”
Marco Island Councilman Glenn Tucker said he wasn’t surprised Moss made Naples’ Top Ten list.
“I assume his credentials spoke for themselves,” Tucker said. “I assume the council saw that and wanted to move forward. Despite what’s been going on on Marco, if you look at them objectively, they’re excellent.”
Moss’ application came less than a week after Marco Island council gave him a 6 percent raise. Once the new pay scale goes into effect, Moss will make $161,000 a year, not including fringe benefits.
The Naples city manager pay scale has been set at $150,000 to $200,000, plus fringe benefits. Current Naples City Manager Bob Lee makes $154,500 a year.
Lee resigned so he could pursue his dream of teaching. He is slated to leave his position on Oct. 19 and begin work as a faculty member at the Askew School of Public Administration at Florida State University in Tallahassee on Nov. 1.
Zimomra has been Sanibel’s city manager for six years.
Freijo told council members that Zimomra explained she “liked a challenge” and this was the only position she has applied for during her tenure as Sanibel city manager.
“My feeling is her education and experience has prepared her for work in Naples,” Freijo said.
Freijo said Cape Coral officials indicated they were sorry to see Rivera go, but needed to make cuts because of budget constraints.
“His leaving had nothing to do with performance,” Freijo said. “He is comfortable working in a community with a high demand for service.”
Absent from the final 10 is former Largo City Manager Susan Stanton.
Stanton, formerly known as Steve Stanton, was fired in March after announcing plans to take steps to become a woman.
Stanton did, however, make the top 16.
“I have interacted with Susan Stanton before and I have always been impressed with the very high quality (of her work),” Freijo said. “She is someone who holds very high standards.”
Candidates will undergo extensive background and reference checks in the coming weeks. City Council will review additional information during the Oct. 15 workshop, where they then will discuss candidates to interview.
Interviews will begin Oct. 22.
Price, who originally was hesitant about the speed of the search, said he is pleased with the progress the city has made.
“I feel good about the process,” Price said. “I think we need to know a lot more (about the candidates). But in my opinion, if one or two stand out, I would support them. (If there isn’t), I’m not going to do anything, but I don’t think we should hold up the process.”
Council is expected to make a decision by Oct. 23, with the new city manager starting by the end of the year.
Staff Writer Liam Dillon contributed to this report.
Webified
- POLL: In the wake of Bill Moss' positive review, pay raise and talk of departure, do you approve of the job he is doing?
- RELATED: 61 apply for Naples city manager job (09-28-07)
- RELATED: Marco's Bill Moss seeking Naples manager position (09-24-07)
- RELATED: Bill Moss' e-mail to councilors about interest in Naples city manager job (09-24-07)
- RELATED: Marco city manager gets high marks from council (09-17-07)

Comments
This site does not necessarily agree with comments posted below — responsibility lies with the relevant reader alone. Read our privacy policy & user agreement.
Bill Moss is by far the best canidate for this job, we love him here on Marco. It would be terrible losing him, Thanx for nuth'n Naples.
#1 Posted by lowus on October 1, 2007 at 4:17 p.m. (Suggest removal)
With all the controversy surroundng Bill Moss's leadership on Marco, I can't imagine that Naples would like to have him run things in their town. It certainly would not be in their best interest to take on a CM who has caused so much discontent in a neighoring town. Naples would do much better if they hire a fresh new face to their city staff, rather than one who is too close to the problems that he created and ruled over.
#2 Posted by blondie on October 2, 2007 at 2:48 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Bill Moss did not create problems on Marco, he solved them and upgraded our City in line with the desires and direction of the City Council. I suggest that anyone who questions Mr. Moss' abilities research the amount of staff and budget for Naples (same size and population as Marco) and Venice (same size and population of Marco) and then look at the number of employees and budget for Marco. That is a City Manager for you.
Ed Issler
#3 Posted by lauralbi1 on October 2, 2007 at 3:24 p.m. (Suggest removal)
lauralbi1/Ed Issler: Comparing Marco Island to Naples is like comparing Naples to Orlando. Naples is the County Seat and as such has certain responsibilities to the county that Marco Island does not. Although similar in population (excuding permanent residents) and geograpical area, you ignore the developed infrastructure, local and regional transportation, health and safety responsibilities along with the huge difference in tax base. Naples has many more millionairs then Marco Island per square mile. Naples parks and public property responsiblities also connot be compared to those of Marco Island. Naples enjoys far greater political clout in the County and State then Marco Island ever will. One day the citizens of Marco Island may even see an advantage to be annexed by the City of Naples (not the other way around). You also ignore the fact that there are greater business and investment oppurtunities in Naples then Marco Island. The Naples Chamber of Commerce lists over 17,000 members employing more than 60,000 employees. As usual,your comments continue to be irrational and limited to facts to fit your argument. Fortunately, most locals know all this and will let your comment slide. I suggest you try harder and learn about the region you reside in before you try to make comparisons.
#4 Posted by Hawke1 on October 3, 2007 at 6:59 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Post your comment
(Requires free registration.)